RIP Shadow Daddy? Why Readers Are Falling for “Wendells” in 2026
For the last five years, the Urban Fantasy and Romantasy charts have been ruled by a single, monolithic figure: The Shadow Daddy.
You know him. He is 500 years old (but looks 25). He wears all black. He is morally grey, possesses world-ending power, and has a tragic backstory that excuses his brooding silence. He is the High Lord of the Night/Darkness/Shadows, and he would burn the world down for the protagonist.
But in 2026, the wind has changed. The “Alpha Hole” archetype is seeing a sharp decline in reader favor. Fatigue has set in. Readers are no longer just looking for a partner who will burn the world down; they’re looking for a partner who will help them survive it—and maybe make them laugh while doing it.
Here are the three relationship dynamics replacing the Shadow Daddy in 2026.
1. Enter “The Wendell”: The Era of the Dramatic Love Interest
If the Shadow Daddy is stoic, “The Wendell” is chaotic.
Named after the high-drama energy of characters who are competent but endlessly complaining, this archetype is taking over. The Wendell is powerful, yes, but he’s also likely to be vain, dramatic, or hilariously high-maintenance.
Readers in 2026 are gravitating toward competence porn mixed with personality. They want a love interest who can slay the demon, but who will also bicker with the protagonist about getting gore on his velvet coat. This shift represents a desire for banter over brooding. It moves the fantasy relationship away from “ownership” (he protects her) to “partnership” (they annoy each other, but they get the job done).
2. The Platonic Soulmate: Intimacy Without the Bedroom
Perhaps the most radical shift in 2026 is the rise of the Platonic Soulbond.
For years, “Soulmates” in fantasy implied a sexual destiny. But a massive segment of the indie market is now devouring books where the deepest, most unbreakable bond is non-romantic.
We are seeing a surge in male/female leads who are literally soul-bound—sharing magic, pain, and telepathy—but who have zero romantic interest in each other. They are “battle spouses” without the marriage. This trend speaks to a reader desire for deep, ride-or-die loyalty that doesn’t rely on the “will-they-won’t-they” sexual tension.
Author Note: In my own series, The Spirit Saga, I explore similar deep, non-romantic loyalties between spirits navigating the afterlife economy. Sometimes the person watching your back isn’t your lover—it’s your coworker.
3. The “Vampire Hockey” Pivot: The Supernatural Sports Romance
Finally, we have to talk about the strangest and most lucrative crossover of the year: Urban Fantasy Sports Romance.
It sounds absurd on paper, but the data is undeniable. As contemporary hockey romance exploded in the early 2020s on platforms like TikTok, it was only a matter of time before it bled into fantasy. Now, we are seeing the rise of “Magical Sports” sub-genres.
Think Teen Wolf meets The Deal. These stories take the popular tropes of sports romance—the team dynamics, the forced proximity on the bus, the “puck bunny” culture, the rivalry—and add fangs. Whether it’s a werewolf rugby league or a vampire hockey team, these books allow authors to utilize the high-stakes adrenaline of sports to drive the plot, replacing the traditional “war” or “murder investigation” of standard Urban Fantasy.
The Takeaway
The Urban Fantasy romance market in 2026 is softening. The edges are less sharp, the humor is louder, and the stakes are more personal. The Shadow Daddy isn’t gone, but he’s having to share the stage with the dramatic wizard, the platonic best friend, and the werewolf goalie.
For authors, the message is clear: You don’t always have to write the dark, brooding anti-hero. Sometimes, you just need a guy who loves drama as much as he loves the protagonist.
Want to see how I tackle relationship dynamics in the afterlife? Join my newsletter to get a free starter library of The Spirit Saga.
Share this:
Discover more from Brian Thompson Writes
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.